IAMU Research Project for Young Academic Staff FY2018 Final Report
Development of Standard Accident/Incident Analysis Forms
| Publication Year | 2019 |
| Research Coordinator | Tuba KECECI |
| Research Partners | Veysel GOKCEK |
| Publisher | International Association of Maritime Universities (IAMU) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.68436/ryas201806 |
Abstract
The hazardous structure of onboard operations makes the existence of dangerous occurrences unavoidable, which might substantially damage human life, the environment, and also the commodity. In accordance with IMO requirements, to prevent accidents or to minimize their impacts, all marine accidents/incidents should be reported and analyzed without any delay. Through investigating ship accidents, it is aimed to determine the root causes that cause hazardous situation and to implement appropriate corrective and preventive actions. The analysis is carried out according to the procedures of shipping companies. However, the structure of the analysis forms used by shipping companies is quite different from each other. To demonstrate this situation, the structure of analysis forms used by different international shipping companies were reviewed. While some shipping companies use a form as short as one page which is not satisfying for in depth analysis of complex marine accidents, some shipping companies use forms designed in detail. To bring an improvement in accident investigation, standardization in the analysis of accident/incident & near miss is a need. In this project, it is aimed to fit the structure of existing maritime accident/incident analysis &reporting forms to a standard to enable standardization. Within the scope of this research, international regulations and standards on accident/incident analysis were examined. Shipping company procedures were reviewed and a literature review was conducted. The needs of the maritime sector tried to be captured by holding workshops, and a standard accident/incident and near miss analysis and reporting form was developed. Study results were validated both by expert-judgment validation method and by case study application. This research will be a novel study in which current ship accident analysis forms were put into a standardized format. It will contribute to improving safety culture in the maritime sector.
Executive summary
One of the essential concerns in the maritime sector is to increase safety and to reduce pollution caused by ship accidents and incidents, as we know that disastrous maritime accidents can cause significant damage to the economy, human life, and the environment. It is not possible to eliminate maritime accidents according to the unique structure of work environment, whereas a major objective is to reduce accidents, to reduce the likelihood of accidents and minimize the severity of the associated results. Thus, to increase safety and to protect the marine environment better by avoiding repetition, it is of great importance to investigate the ship accidents by experts and to deliver the outputs to the authorities. In order to prevent or minimize accidents, all marine accidents/incidents should be reported and analyzed without delay under IMO regulations. It is aimed to determine the root causes for applying appropriate strategic actions in order to prevent recurrence by investigating ship accidents. The analysis in this project follows the procedures of shipping companies. In addition to that, the structure of the analysis forms used by shipping companies varies considerably. To illustrate this situation, the structure of the analysis forms used by various international shipping companies were reviewed. While some shipping companies use a short form that is not satisfactory for in-depth analysis of complex marine accidents, some maritime shipping companies use elaborate forms. Besides, each company uses different techniques for root cause analysis of ship accidents and does not have a standard taxonomy used in the maritime domain. Facilitation is needed regarding standardization of root cause taxonomy in occurrence reporting, follow-up, and improvement in the analysis. In order to establish a common approach to safety, it is considered that a standard root cause terminology list should be developed for use in the analysis section of the standard form. In this project, we proposed an accident/incident and near-miss analysis & reporting form which is not designed for a specific ship type or ship operation. This form is proposed to be used by shipping companies for internal use and it is not the reporting form that is used by the maritime authorities. It was structured to easy to implement with new standards and regulations. To improve project outcomes in the maritime domain, two workshops were held. A network for the working group of shipping companies operating different types of ships in international waters was established. Oceangoing masters from General Directorate of Coastal Safety were also invited to the network. A Member from Turkish Accident Investigation Board joined the group in order to improve our research results. In addition, a sub-working group was established. A literature review was applied, including the paper which was extracted from the project coordinator's Ph.D. thesis, and accident investigation boards’ recent investigation reports during the taxonomy development process. The ships listed in the reports reviewed had different types and sizes. In addition, the accident analysis forms of eleven shipping companies were examined. The root causes in the forms were identified and recorded. All of the resources mentioned above were analyzed to form a list of root causes. Based on the expert opinion, a new root cause evaluation taxonomy was developed. Developed root cause evaluation taxonomy was validated by the project staff. For every category and root cause, there's a unique "ID" code to make it easy to cite, ‘H’ for human factors and ‘J’ for Job-related factors. Human-related root causes were grouped under six main headings. These are Human Behaviour, Human Characteristics, Physical/Physiological Capacity-Stress, Psychological Capacity-Stress, Inadequate Knowledge, Skill, Training, and Factors for Lack of Motivation, respectively. Job-related root causes were grouped under eleven main headings. These are Communication Problems, Inadequate Leadership, Inadequate Team Culture, Safety-Related Issues, Inadequate Manning Level, Problems Related to System and/or Its Application, Inadequacy in Ship Construction, Design and Equipment, Cargo-Related Issues, Environmental Factors, Third-Party Related Factors, and Commercial Pressure, respectively. At the beginning of the project studies, we decided to develop an analysis form for accident and incident cases. However, by reviewing the output of workshops, the need for a proactive approach arise. So we included the near-miss event to the project studies. The company representative suggested to combine analysis and reporting forms and an accident/incident and near-miss analysis & reporting form structure was designed. Following, the final version of the standard analysis & reporting form was generated and validated upon applying in maritime accident/incidents and through the expert-judgment validation method. In order to finalize the developed analysis & reporting form, the Delphi method in which the level of the experts’ agreement was calculated using the Fleiss Kappa statistic and shown by Kappa value. After the validation step, a guideline containing information regarding the standard form was prepared. This project will serve as a novel example to fit existing maritime accident/incident analysis to a certain standard. All the work carried out in this study will contribute to the development of safety culture in the maritime domain.
Keywords
Marine Accident, accident analysis, safety, standardization
References
- IMO, “Resolution A.884(21), Amendments to the Code for the Investigation of Marine Casualties and Incidents resolution A.849(20),” (1999).
- UNCTAD, “Merchant fleet by country of beneficial ownership, annual, 2014 – 2018.” [Online]. Available: https://unctadstat.unctad.org/wds/ReportFolders/reportFolders.aspx. [Accessed: 01-Feb-2019].
- EMSA, “The Annual Overview of Marine Casualties and Incidents 2018,” (2018).
- JTSB, “Statistics (Marine).” [Online]. Available: http://www.mlit.go.jp/jtsb/statistics_mar.html. [Accessed: 01-Mar-2019].
- T. Kececi and O. Arslan, “SHARE technique: a novel approach to root cause analysis of ship accidents,” Saf. Sci., vol. 96, pp. 1–21, (2017).
- M. H. Nordquist (Hrsg.), “United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1982, A Commentary,” Verfassung R. und Übersee, (2017).
- IMO, International safety management (ISM) code with guidelines for its implementation, 2018th ed. (2018).
- J. Rasmussen, “Human errors. A taxonomy for describing human malfunction in industrial installations,” J. Occup. Accid., (1982).
- J. Reason, Human error. Cambridge university press, (1990).
- J. Reason, Managing the risks of organizational accidents. 1-84014-105-0, Ashgate, England, Aldershot (1997).
- F. H. Hawkins, Human factors in flight. Gower Technical Press, Aldershot, UK (1987)
- R. Reinhart, Basic flight physiology. McGraw Hill Professional, (2007).
- S.-T. Chen, A. Wall, P. Davies, Z. Yang, J. Wang, and Y.-H. Chou, “A Human and Organisational Factors (HOFs) analysis method for marine casualties using HFACS-Maritime Accidents (HFACS-MA),” Saf. Sci., vol. 60, pp. 105–114, (2013).
- M. C. G. S. P. Bandeira, A. R. Correia, and M. R. Martins, “General model analysis of aeronautical accidents involving human and organizational factors,” J. Air Transp. Manag., vol. 69, pp. 137–146, (2018).
- M. Celik and S. Cebi, “Analytical HFACS for investigating human errors in shipping accidents,” Accid. Anal. Prev., vol. 41, no. 1, pp. 66–75, (2009).
- J. U. Schröder-Hinrichs, M. Baldauf, and K. T. Ghirxi, “Accident investigation reporting deficiencies related to organizational factors in machinery space fires and explosions,” Accid. Anal. Prev., vol. 43, no. 3, pp. 1187–1196, (2011).
- S.-T. Chen and Y.-H. Chou, “Examining Human Factors for marine casualties using HFACS-maritime accidents (HFACS-MA),” in 2012 12th International Conference on ITS Telecommunications, (2012), pp. 391–396.
- P. M. Salmon, M. A. Regan, and I. Johnston, Human error and road transport: Phase one–Literature review, no. 256. (2005).
- S. Sklet, “Comparison of some selected methods for accident investigation,” in Journal of Hazardous Materials, (2004).
- H. Yuniarto, “The shortcomings of existing root cause analysis tools,” in Proceedings of the World Congress on Engineering, (2012), vol. 3, pp. 4–6.
- IMO, “Resolution A/ES.IV/Res.173, Participation in Official Inquiries into Maritime Casualties,” (1968).
- IMO, “Resolution A.322(IX), Conduct of Investigations into Casualties,” (1975).
- IMO, “Resolution A.440(XI), Exchange of Information for Investigations into Marine Casualties,” (1979).
- IMO, “Resolution A.637(16), Co-operation in Maritime Casualty Investigations,” (1989).
- IMO, “Resolution A.442(XI), Personnel and Material Resource Needs of Administrations for the Investigation of Casualties and the Contravention of Conventions.”
- IMO, “A.849(20) ,Code for the Investigation of Marine Casualties and Incidents,” (1997).
- IMO, “Resolution MSC.255(84), Adoption of the Code of the International Standards and Recommended Practices for a Safety Investigation into a Marine Casualty Or Marine Incident (Casualty Investigation Code),” (2008).
- IMO, “Resolution A. 1075(28), Guidelines to assist investigators in the implementation of the Casualty Investigation Code (resolution MSC.255(84)),” (2013).
- IMO, “Casualty Analysis Procedure, (document FSI 17/WP.1, annex 2).”
- IMO, “MSC-MEPC.3/Circ.3, Casualty-Related Matters Reports on Marine Casualties and Incidents,” (2008).
- IMO, “Report to the Maritime Safety Committee and the Marine Environment Protection Committee, FSI 21/18,” (2013).
- I. Nurrohmah, D. I. Sensuse, and H. B. Santoso, “The expert-judgement validation and finalization of proposed interaction design process maturity instrument: Case study: E-commerce in Indonesia,” in 2017 Second International Conference on Informatics and Computing (ICIC), (2017), pp. 1–6.
- G. Aichholzer, “The delphi method: Eliciting experts’ knowledge in technology foresight,” in Interviewing experts, Springer, (2009), pp. 252–274.
- M. Zuo and H. Fu, “Enterprise informatization maturity model based on delphi method,” in Research and Practical Issues of Enterprise Information Systems II, Springer, 2008, pp. 1117–1126.
- M. L. McHugh, “Interrater reliability: the kappa statistic,” Biochem. medica Biochem. medica, vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 276–282, (2012).
- J. R. Landis and G. G. Koch, “An application of hierarchical kappa-type statistics in the assessment of majority agreement among multiple observers,” Biometrics, pp. 363–374, (1977).
- R. L. Brennan and D. J. Prediger, “Coefficient kappa: Some uses, misuses, and alternatives,” Educ. Psychol. Meas., vol. 41, no. 3, pp. 687–699, (1981).