IAMU Research Project for Young Academic Staff FY2022 Final Report
A way to green voyage for LNG-fuelled ships: onboard Organic Rankine Cycle combined with Carbon Capture and Storage system
| Publication Year | 2023 |
| Research Coordinator | Zhen TIAN |
| Research Partners | Wenzhong Gao; Yuan Zhang; Chao Yang; Hao Peng; Haiyan Yu |
| Publisher | International Association of Maritime Universities (IAMU) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.68436/ryas20220201 |
Abstract
The MEPC has called for 50% decarbonization from the shipping industry from 2008 levels by the end of 2050. In the context of this background, liquefied nature gas (LNG) is regarded as the most feasible fuel for ships. Before LNG burning in the dual-fuel engine, LNG needs to vaporize and overheat, during which about 860 kJ/kg cold energy would be discharged. On the other hand, about 50% of the fuel energy is lost as heat. Therefore, the efficient utilization of LNG cold energy and waste heat is of great significance to ship energy conservation and emission reduction. This report aims at exploring the feasibility of decarbonation for the LNG-fueled ships. The Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) system is used to achieve the EEDI requirement in phase 3. Novelty, this work proposes the onboard organic Rankine cycle (ORC)
combined with CCS to pursue the zero energy increasement for CCS. The ORC-CCS simulation model is established in Aspen HYSYS. Thermal and economic performances are studied under several different scenarios to reflect the circumstances in practice. The analyses of CO2 emission reduction of LNG-fueled ship based on its economic feasibility are carried out. Moreover, a pilot-scale CCS is designed and manufactured. The results of this work would provide technical reference for improving energy efficiency and green shipping.
Executive summary
This project aims at improving ship energy efficiency, reducing CO2 emission and fulfilling green voyage. The details include:
Recovering cold energy and waste heat of LNG-felled ships via Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC).
Investigating the feasibility of onboard Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) system.
Analyze the configuration of the ORC-CCS for the reference ship.
Providing support material for the EEDI revision for LNG-fueled ships.
To achieve the four objectives, we conduct a systematic literature review and the possibility of LNG cold energy and waste heat recovery is theoretically analyzed. Based on the guideline of EEDI, the amount of CO2 reduction is determined, which provide the design instructions for the ORC-CCS system. Furthermore, a refence ship is selected for ORC-CCS system design and modelling development from two aspects. Firstly, the onboard CCS is designed and numerically studied from thermo-economic aspect. Secondly, the combined ORC-CCS is simulated and analyzed from energy, exergy and economic perspective with the variation of working parameters. At last, a pilot scale CCS system is designed and manufactured.
The main finds of this project are as follows. The EEDI requirement for the reference ship is calculated and the CO2 reduction for meeting the EEDI phases is determined. The LNG cold energy could be utilized for ORC power generation and CO2 capture. It concludes that the LNG cold energy utilization technologies are relatively mature, and they have been widely adopted in the onshore conditions. A Kamsarmax vessel is taken as an example and the plasticity of the system is analyzed from three perspectives: energy, exergy and economic via Aspen HYSYS. The CCS optimum operating parameters are mexh 20000 kg/h, msol 16000 kg/h. The amount of CO2 captured at this point is 760.4 kg/h, which is well above EEDI Stage 3 requirements. The total initial cost of CCS is 1.38 million US $. Under the designed working conditions, the ORC system can generate enough electricity to fully meet the system's electricity demand. The maximum power generated by the ORC is 123.7 kW and CO2 capture rate also reaches 78.64%. Meanwhile, the system exergy efficiency increases from 19.59% to 28.03%. Increasing the exhaust gas flow rate will increase the amount of captured CO2, but there is an upper limit to the capture amount. When the solution flow rate is 21000 kg/h and the exhaust gas flow rate is 20000 kg/h, the maximum amount of captured CO2 is 1686 kg/h. As the CO2 capture amount changes slowly and the regeneration heat changes significantly with the solution, the specific reboiler duty also increases from 4.62GJ/tonCO2 to 4.71GJ/tonCO2. The equipment capital investment is mainly from the heat exchanger, which accounts for 48.5%.
In our research, the results are consistent and convincing. For the future research, there is a need to investigate the details of different ship types to generate a universal guideline for EEDI revision. Also, the dynamic simulation and experimental validation of the proposed system should be carried out. All these point out the potential direction for the near future research.
The research deliverables also include:
We shared two presentations for the AGA 22 titled “Feasibility study on carbon capture system of LNG-fueled ship based on comprehensive utilization of heat and cold energy” and “A way to green voyage for LNG-fueled ships: onboard Organic Rankine Cycle combined with Carbon Capture and Storage system”. The conference paper has been published on “22nd Annual General Assembly of the International Association of Maritime Universities Conference, AGA IAMUC 2022”.
We have submitted two talks to AGA 23, including Paper 1 titled “A Zero Energy Increment Onboard Carbon Capture System for LNG-fueled Ship” and Paper 2 titled “Thermo-economic analysis on OCCS of LNG dual-fuel vessels based on the EEDI framework”.
Keywords
LNG-fueled ships, Green voyage, Organic Rankine Cycle, Carbon Capture and Storage, EEDI
References
- IMO, Counts Down To Sulphur 2020, Limiting Air Pollution From Ships, in, 2019.
- Lion, et al., A review of emissions reduction technologies for low and medium speed marine Diesel engines and their potential for waste heat recovery, Energy Conversion and Management, 207 (2020) 112553.
- Sharples, LNG Supply Chains and the Development of LNG as a Shipping Fuel in Northern Europe, (2019).
- IMO, 2021 GUIDANCE ON TREATMENT OF INNOVATIVE ENERGY EFFICIENCY TECHNOLOGIES FOR CALCULATION AND VERIFICATION OF THE ATTAINED EEDI AND EEXI https://wwwcdn.imo.org/localresources/en/OurWork/Environment/Documents/Air%20pollution/MEPC.1-Circ.896.pdf.
- Gao, et al., Experimental investigation on an R290-based organic Rankine cycle utilizing cold energy of liquid nitrogen, Applied Thermal Engineering, 202 (2022).
- Chong, et al., Economic evaluation of energy efficient hydrate based desalination utilizing cold energy from liquefied natural gas (LNG), Desalination, 463 (2019) 69-80.
- Kanbur, et al., Thermoeconomic and environmental assessments of a combined cycle for the small scale LNG cold utilization, Applied Energy, 204 (2017) 1148-1162.
- IGU, World LNG Report, International Gas Union .2020 Edition, (2020).
- Wu, et al., Combined biomass gasification, SOFC, IC engine, and waste heat recovery system for power and heat generation: Energy, exergy, exergoeconomic, environmental (4E) evaluations, Applied Energy, 279 (2020).
- Yan, et al., Experimental and theoretical analysis of bubble rising velocity in a 3î3 rolling rod bundle under stagnant condition, Annals of Nuclear Energy, 72 (2014) 471-481.
- Pendyala, et al., Flow and pressure drop fluctuations in a vertical tube subject to low frequency oscillations, Nuclear Engineering and Design, 238 (2008) 178-187.
- Tian, et al., Multi-Objective Thermo-Economic Optimization of a Combined Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) System Based on Waste Heat of Dual Fuel Marine Engine and LNG Cold Energy Recovery, Energies, 13 (2020).
- Liu, et al., A novel inlet air cooling system based on liquefied natural gas cold energy utilization for improving power plant performance, Energy Conversion and Management, 187 (2019) 41-52.
- Yao, et al., Design and optimization of LNG vaporization cold energy comprehensive utilization system based on a novel intermediate fluid vaporizer, Applied Thermal Engineering, 190 (2021).
- Sadeghi, et al., Exergoeconomic analysis and multi-objective optimization of an ejector refrigeration cycle powered by an internal combustion (HCCI) engine, Energy Conversion and Management, 96 (2015) 403-417.
- Kanbur, et al., Cold utilization systems of LNG: A review, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 79 (2017) 1171-1188.
- Li, et al., Performance analysis of an improved power generation system utilizing the cold energy of LNG and solar energy, Applied Thermal Engineering, 159 (2019).
- Kim, et al., Power augmentation of combined cycle power plants using cold energy of liquefied natural gas, Energy, 25 (2000) 841-856.
- Park, et al., Novel massive thermal energy storage system for liquefied natural gas cold energy recovery, Energy, 195 (2020).
- Mehrpooya, et al., Optimum design and exergy analysis of a novel cryogenic air separation process with LNG (liquefied natural gas) cold energy utilization, Energy, 90 (2015) 2047-2069.
- Ghorbani, et al., Investigation of a hybrid water desalination, oxy-fuel power generation and CO2 liquefaction process, Energy, 158 (2018) 1105-1119.
- He, et al., A novel conceptual design of hydrate based desalination (HyDesal) process by utilizing LNG cold energy, Applied Energy, 222 (2018) 13-24.
- Gao, et al., Improved processes of light hydrocarbon separation from LNG with its cryogenic energy utilized, Energy Conversion and Management, 52 (2011) 2401-2404.
- He, et al., LNG cold energy utilization: Prospects and challenges, Energy, 170 (2019) 557-568.
- Qi, et al., Advanced integration of LNG regasification power plant with liquid air energy storage: Enhancements in flexibility, safety, and power generation, Applied Energy, 269 (2020). 澳
- Li, et al., Design, improvements and applications of dual-pressure evaporation organic Rankine cycles: A review, Applied Energy, 311 (2022) 118609.
- Jafary, et al., A complete energetic and exergetic analysis of a solar powered trigeneration system with two novel organic Rankine cycle (ORC) configurations, Journal of Cleaner Production, 281 (2021) 124552.
- Ahmadi, et al., Applications of geothermal organic Rankine Cycle for electricity production, Journal of Cleaner Production, 274 (2020) 122950.
- Khanmohammadi, et al., Proposal of a novel integrated ocean thermal energy conversion system with flat plate solar collectors and thermoelectric generators: Energy, exergy and environmental analyses, Journal of Cleaner Production, 256 (2020) 120600.
- Ma, et al., Multi-stage Rankine cycle (MSRC) model for LNG cold-energy power generation system, Energy, 165 (2018) 673-688.
- Bao, et al., Comparative study of liquefied natural gas (LNG) cold energy power generation systems in series and parallel, Energy Conversion and Management, 184 (2019) 107-126.
- Gomez, et al., Review of thermal cycles exploiting the exergy of liquefied natural gas in the regasification process, Renewable & Sustainable Energy Reviews, 38 (2014) 781-795.
- Sun, et al., Thermodynamic optimization and comparative study of different ORC configurations utilizing the exergies of LNG and low grade heat of different temperatures, Energy, 147 (2018) 688-700.
- Sun, et al., Multi-parameter optimization and fluid selection guidance of a two-stage organic Rankine cycle utilizing LNG cold energy and low grade heat, Energy Procedia, 142 (2017) 1222-1229.
- Mehrpooya, et al., Cost and economic potential analysis of a cascading power cycle with liquefied natural gas regasification, Energy Conversion and Management, 156 (2018) 68-83.
- Choi, et al., Analysis and optimization of cascade Rankine cycle for liquefied natural gas cold energy recovery, Energy, 61 (2013) 179-195.
- Bao, et al., The effect of the arrangements for compression process and expansion process on the performance of the two-stage condensation Rankine cycle, Energy Conversion and Management, 159 (2018) 299-311.
- Xue, et al., Thermodynamic analysis and optimization of a two-stage organic Rankine cycle for liquefied natural gas cryogenic exergy recovery, Energy, 83 (2015) 778-787.
- Jamali, et al., Recovery of liquefied natural gas cold energy in a clean cogeneration system utilizing concentrated photovoltaics, Journal of Cleaner Production, 350 (2022) 131517.
- Joy, et al., Enhancing generation of green power from the cold of vaporizing LNG at 30 bar by optimising heat exchanger surface area in a multi-staged organic Rankine cycle, Sustainable Energy Technologies and Assessments, 43 (2021) 100930.
- Tian, et al., Energy, exergy, and economic (3E) analysis of an organic Rankine cycle using zeotropic mixtures based on marine engine waste heat and LNG cold energy, Energy Conversion and Management, 228 (2021) 113657.
- He, et al., Effects of cooling and heating sources properties and working fluid selection on cryogenic organic Rankine cycle for LNG cold energy utilization, Energy Conversion and Management, 247 (2021) 114706.
- Choi, et al., Optimal design of organic Rankine cycle recovering LNG cold energy with finite heat exchanger size, Energy, 217 (2021) 119268.
- Mosaffa, et al., Thermodynamic feasibility evaluation of an innovative salinity gradient solar ponds-based ORC using a zeotropic mixture as working fluid and LNG cold energy, Applied Thermal Engineering, 186 (2021) 116488.
- Oil and Gas Climate Initiative and Stena Bulk. Is carbon capture on ships feasible? A report from the oil and gas climate initiative [online], in, 2021.
- Pan, et al., Design and analysis of LNG cold energy cascade utilization system integrating light hydrocarbon separation, organic Rankine cycle and direct cooling, Applied Thermal Engineering, 213 (2022) 118672.
- Tian, et al., A novel negative carbon-emission, cooling, and power generation system based on combined LNG regasification and waste heat recovery: Energy, exergy, economic, environmental (4E) evaluations, Energy, 257 (2022) 124528.
- Lecompte, et al., Review of organic Rankine cycle (ORC) architectures for waste heat recovery, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 47 (2015) 448-461. 澳
- Marandi, et al., An efficient auxiliary power generation system for exploiting hydrogen boil-off gas (BOG) cold exergy based on PEM fuel cell and two-stage ORC: Thermodynamic and exergoeconomic viewpoints, Energy Conversion and Management, 195 (2019) 502-518.
- Li, et al., Thermodynamic and economic evaluation of the organic Rankine cycle (ORC) and two-stage series organic Rankine cycle (TSORC) for flue gas heat recovery, Energy Conversion and Management, 183 (2019) 816-829.
- Surendran, et al., Performance investigation of two stage Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) architectures using induction turbine layouts in dual source waste heat recovery, Energy Conversion and Management: X, 6 (2020) 100029.
- Braimakis, et al., Exergetic efficiency potential of double-stage ORCs with zeotropic mixtures of natural hydrocarbons and CO2, Energy, 218 (2021) 119577.
- Xi, et al., Parametric optimization of regenerative organic Rankine cycle (ORC) for low grade waste heat recovery using genetic algorithm, Energy, 58 (2013) 473-482.
- Aliahmadi, et al., Multi-objective optimization of regenerative ORC system integrated with thermoelectric generators for low-temperature waste heat recovery, Energy Reports, 7 (2021) 300-313.
- Braimakis, et al., Energetic optimization of regenerative Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) configurations, Energy Conversion and Management, 159 (2018) 353-370.
- Cao, et al., Optimum design and thermodynamic analysis of a gas turbine and ORC combined cycle with recuperators, Energy Conversion and Management, 116 (2016) 32-41.
- Pei, et al., Analysis of low temperature solar thermal electric generation using regenerative Organic Rankine Cycle, Applied Thermal Engineering, 30 (2010) 998-1004.
- Mosaffa, et al., Thermo-economic analysis of combined different ORCs geothermal power plants and LNG cold energy, Geothermics, 65 (2017) 113-125.
- Mehrpooya, et al., Thermoeconomic analysis and optimization of a regenerative two-stage organic Rankine cycle coupled with liquefied natural gas and solar energy, Energy, 126 (2017) 899-914.
- Imran, et al., Thermo-economic optimization of Regenerative Organic Rankine Cycle for waste heat recovery applications, Energy Conversion and Management, 87 (2014) 107-118.
- Choi, et al., Thermodynamic analysis of a dual loop heat recovery system with trilateral cycle applied to exhaust gases of internal combustion engine for propulsion of the 6800 TEU container ship, Energy, 58 (2013) 404-416.
- Lee, et al., Thermodynamic assessment of integrated heat recovery system combining exhaust-gas heat and cold energy for LNG regasification process in FSRU vessel, Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology, 30 (2016) 1389-1398.
- Soffiato, et al., Design optimization of ORC systems for waste heat recovery on board a LNG carrier, Energy Conversion and Management, 92 (2015) 523-534.
- Sung, et al., Thermodynamic analysis of a novel dual-loop organic Rankine cycle for engine waste heat and LNG cold, Applied Thermal Engineering, 100 (2016) 1031-1041.
- Tian, et al., Thermo-economic analysis and optimization of a combined Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) system with LNG cold energy and waste heat recovery of dual-fuel marine engine, International Journal of Energy Research, 44 (2020) 9974-9994.
- Sun, et al., Design and Optimization of a Full-Generation System for Marine LNG Cold Energy Cascade Utilization, Journal of Thermal Science, 29 (2020) 587-596.
- Wilberforce, et al., Progress in carbon capture technologies, Sci Total Environ, 761 (2021) 143203.
- Zhao, et al., Cold energy utilization of liquefied natural gas for capturing carbon dioxide in the flue gas from the magnesite processing industry, Energy, 105 (2016) 45-56.
- Gomez, et al., Thermodynamic analysis of a novel power plant with LNG (liquefied natural gas) cold exergy exploitation and CO2 capture, Energy, 105 (2016) 32-44.
- Mehrpooya, et al., Introducing a novel air separation process based on cold energy recovery of LNG integrated with coal gasification, transcritical carbon dioxide power cycle and cryogenic CO2 capture, Journal of Cleaner Production, 142 (2017) 1749-1764. 澳
- Aghaie, et al., Introducing an integrated chemical looping hydrogen production, inherent carbon capture and solid oxide fuel cell biomass fueled power plant process configuration, Energy Conversion and Management, 124 (2016) 141-154.
- Liu, et al., Performance analysis of a CCHP system based on SOFC/GT/CO2 cycle and ORC with LNG cold energy utilization, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 44 (2019) 29700-29710.
- Liu, et al., Thermoeconomic analysis of a novel zero-CO2-emission high-efficiency power cycle using LNG coldness, Energy Conversion and Management, 50 (2009) 2768-2781.
- Wang, et al., A novel combined system for LNG cold energy utilization to capture carbon dioxide in the flue gas from the magnesite processing industry, Energy, 187 (2019) 115963.
- Pan, et al., Thermodynamic analysis of KCS/ORC integrated power generation system with LNG cold energy exploitation and CO2 capture, Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering, 46 (2017) 188-198.
- Xu, et al., A CO2 cryogenic capture system for flue gas of an LNG-fired power plant, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy, 42 (2017) 18674-18680.
- Bao, et al., Reduction of efficiency penalty for a natural gas combined cycle power plant with post-combustion CO2 capture: Integration of liquid natural gas cold energy, Energy Conversion and Management, 198 (2019) 111852.
- Feenstra, et al., Ship-based carbon capture onboard of diesel or LNG-fuelled ships, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 85 (2019) 1-10.
- Seo, et al., Evaluation of CO2 liquefaction processes for ship-based carbon capture and storage (CCS) in terms of life cycle cost (LCC) considering availability, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 35 (2015) 1-12.
- Fang, et al., Optimal Sizing of Shipboard Carbon Capture System for Maritime Greenhouse Emission Control, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, 55 (2019) 5543-5553.
- Long, et al., Improvement of marine carbon capture onboard diesel fueled ships, Chemical Engineering and Processing – Process Intensification, 168 (2021) 108535.
- Ros, et al., Advancements in ship-based carbon capture technology on board of LNG-fuelled ships, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 114 (2022) 103575.
- Einbu, et al., Energy assessments of onboard CO2 capture from ship engines by MEA-based post combustion capture system with flue gas heat integration, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, 113 (2022) 103526.
- J, Exergy method: technical and ecological applications, WIT Press, UK, 2005.