IAMU Research Project FY2016 Final Report
Data Alternatives for Marine Efficiency Monitoring
| Publication Year | 2017 |
| Research Coordinator | Ruurd van der Meer |
| Research Partners | Geraint Phylip-Jones; Marcel·la Castells; Clara Borén; Jordi Torralbo; Santiago Ordás; Robert Kiplimo |
| Publisher | International Association of Maritime Universities (IAMU) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.68436/r20160211 |
Abstract
The implementation of measures to increase the energy efficiency of ships is not so successful as expected. A benchmark is needed to gain insight in the present state of the energy efficiency of ships. That can be used to assess why these measures are less successful as expected and to develop better fitting energy efficiency legislation in the future. Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) is proposed as benchmark methodology. Ships are required to monitor their fuel consumption and/or carbon emissions on annual basis. MRV is believed to close the knowledge gap of ship specific fuel consumption, the best fitting efficiency technologies for ships, and of split incentives and responsibilities across the total sector. There is a European scheme and a global IMO scheme. The reasons why shipping lacks to implement energy efficiency seems as well apply for the implementation of MRV. Shipping argues there is a knowledge gap for the implementation of MRV. Secondly, the monitoring results will be published. That information is considered as confidential and too sensitive for third parties. This study tries to find an alternative method which serves both goals: 1. fuel consumption/carbon emissions are still fully monitored and reported because the specific maritime contribution to global warming is important to know; and 2. the direct fuel consumption/emissions are disclosed and the results have been made anonymously to meet the industry. The latter is done by searching for alternative methods, proxies, parameters which deliver information about fuel consumptions emissions, but which do not directly link to a vessel or present direct information of the fuel consumption. Based on 1. the identification of parameters which are monitored on board presently; 2. making an inventory of methods to calculate fuel consumption and/or CO2 emissions; and 3. evaluation of which parameters sensitivity and/or anonymizing apply using existing monitored parameters two alternative methods for MRV monitoring seem to meet both objectives. The method of using on-board monitoring devices is a method which has the potential of qualifying with the objectives of less sensibility and more anonymity. The potential of this method lies in the way that it can determine the efficiency of ships. And efficiency can be shared as function of energy labels which present ranges of efficiencies and thus less sensible data is shared. Emission modelling could also be an alternative. Ship fuel consumption/fuel consumption is monitored via AIS and models. Subsequently, the results are brought to the vessels. The model results are verified by the ships. If the results are in the same order of magnitude, the modelling results will be published and become available to the market. The specific information will be shared confidentially to the relevant authorities. A list of questions is developed as tool to evaluate the potential of alternative MRV methods. Developers are able to proof with help of the list of questions their method is feasible to use as MRV method. Ship owners might want to develop their own way of monitoring. This list question might close their knowledge gap around MRV.
Executive summary
The implementation of measures to increase the energy efficiency of ships is not so successful as expected. A benchmark is needed to gain insight in the present state of the energy efficiency of ships. That can be used to assess why these measures are less successful as expected and to develop better fitting energy efficiency legislation in the future. Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV) is proposed as benchmark methodology. Ships are required to monitor their fuel consumption and/or carbon emissions on annual basis. MRV is believed to close the knowledge gap of ship specific fuel consumption, the best fitting efficiency technologies for ships, and of split incentives and responsibilities across the total sector. The present way of determining ship emissions its accuracy is too small. There is a European scheme and a global IMO scheme. The reasons why shipping lacks to implement energy efficiency seems as well apply for the implementation of MRV. Shipping argues there is a knowledge gap for the implementation of MRV. Secondly, the monitoring results will be published. That information is considered as confidential and too sensitive for third parties. This study contributes to the discussion of which methodical approaches for MRV could be interesting for the industry to implement. This study raises the premise that values other than direct information about fuel consumption/carbon emissions could be shared too. Such values must present information about the energy performance of a ship without publishing the exact energy performance values. These are proxy values or the results of monitoring methods with different approaches. There is less impediment in relation with anonymity, because the market has merely a direction of the fuel consumption of the vessels. Ships of course still need to share their data with the designated authorities. Though, ship data are treated with care. The research is arranged in three steps:
1. Identifying parameters which are required for energy consumption and emissions on board presently. A theoretical fuel consumption can be calculated by using the energy related parameters in energy and mass balances following from diesel engine theory. One or more parameters could serve as proxy which presents information about the fuel consumption of a vessel – without presenting the direct fuel consumption.
2. Making an inventory of methods to calculate fuel consumption and/or CO2 emissions. A second way of tackling the problem is to find another method for determining the fuel consumption/carbon emissions and which meets the objections from the industry.
3. Evaluating to which parameters sensitivity and/or anonymizing apply to develop an alternative methodology for energy efficiency monitoring by using for example proxies for problematic parameters.
Parallel a literature study has been performed to the basic requirements of a successful monitoring, reporting and verification implementation. This list of questions is developed as tool to evaluate the potential of alternative MRV methods. Developers are able to proof with help of the list of questions their method is feasible to use as MRV method. Ship owners might want to develop their own way of monitoring. This list question might close their knowledge gap around MRV. The potential as alternative method has been assessed by combining the presently monitored parameters and the method inventory. The possible best usable method is found by assessing:
1. if the relevant parameters already are monitored/available on board for the reviewed methods,
2. ranking of methods by scoring for its feasibility (already monitored/available), costs, accuracy, implementation. Methods with a low feasibility are considered less suitable to be used as a method
3. the outcome of each method in relation with research objectives.
A thermo-dynamical analysis of the on-board energy flows is an approach which includes proxies. This analysis makes use of parameters which are already being monitored. The latter is important, because the use of existing infrastructure keeps low the extra workload coming forth from MRV. A proxy in the thermo-dynamical analysis is the energy uptake by other mediums such as cooling water, lubrication and exhaust gasses and other heat losses. Such a method could be useful, but more values are required. The presently monitored parameters are insufficient. Important lacking parameters are mass flows of the various mediums. Secondly this study looked at different approaches as monitoring method which also not present the direct fuel consumption information. The review and method assessment resulted in two useful methodical approaches: the use of on-board measurement equipment and the use of off-ship modelling (CARB and STEAM 2). The method of using on-board monitoring devices is a method which has the potential of qualifying with the objectives of less sensibility and more anonymity. The potential of this method lies in the way and what is being monitored. Ships can monitor other additional relevant energy processes or proxies like efficiency by using measuring and monitoring equipment. Efficiency does not directly show information about direct fuel consumption. And thus by for example monitoring the mass flows of the relevant medium so that the thermo-dynamical method can be used. An important remark concerning the use of efficiency is that the original measures of EEDI and EEIO were focussing on efficiency. MRV has been proposed to force the industry to have a look at its efficiency. It should be kept in mind that by using efficiency the discussion has arrived at its starting point. One could consider the introduction of energy labels for ships to overcome this issue. An energy label shows in which range of efficiencies a particular ship operates. The vessel itself submits its direct information to the relevant authorities for complying with the regulations. This ensures the knowledge of the fuel consumption at the legislative level and enhances the idea of energy efficient ships in the market. The methods need to be assessed to what is further needed in the application of the methods. Emission modelling could also be an alternative. This seems to be strange while on of the rationales of the introduction of MRV is that modelling is not specific enough about ship emissions. However, modelling with the aid of AIS – as in STEAM 2 – is very suitable to use as verification method, analogue to air traffic control in the aviation MRV scheme. To overcome the problems by the industry, the approach could be the other way around. Ship fuel consumption/fuel consumption is monitored via AIS and models. Subsequently, the results are brought to the vessels. The model results are verified by the ships. If the results are in the same order of magnitude, the modelling results will be published and available to the market. The specific information will be shared confidentially to the relevant authorities. An additional outcome of the study is the list of topics and questions which should be asked when considering the development of an MRV scheme and the introduction of a monitoring method. Such a list was not yet available in the maritime context. There is a knowledge gap about the implications of MRV on board and what a proper way of MRV on board could be. These questions could be handful to the industry to the required actions for implementation of MRV. It also helps in the development of MRV methods, because the methods for MRV are not legally prescribed. The list of questions is a first set up, as are the discussed methods. More work is needed to complete this list. At the same time more work is needed to validate the (still) conceptual proposed methods to make these more mature to be eventually used on board.
Keywords
Monitoring, Reporting and Verification; MRV; Ship Energy Efficiency; MRV methods, Ship Emissions
References
- Eyring V., et al. "Transport Impacts on Atmosphere and Climate: Shipping", Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 44, No. 37, (2010), pp 4735-71.
- Carlton J.T., "Pattern, Process, and Prediction in Marine Invasion Ecology", Biological Conservation, Vol. 78, No. 1-2, (1996), pp 97-106.
- Leaper R., Martin R. and Conor R., "Reducing Underwater Noise from Large Commercial Ships: Current Status and Future Directions", Journal of Ocean Technology, Vol. 9, No.1, (2014), pp 51-69.
- Oltmann J-H., "Route Topology Model – 1. Introduction", Web. http://www.accseas.eu/publications/accseas-conference-2015/, (2015).
- IMO, “Third IMO Greenhouse Gas Study 2014”, London: International Maritime Organization, (2015).
- Psaraftis H.N. and Kontovas C.A., "Speed Models for Energy-Efficient Maritime Transportation: A Taxonomy and Survey", Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies, Vol. 26, (2013), pp 331-51.
- De Simio L., Gambino M. and Iannaccone S., "Possible Transport Energy Sources for the Future", Transport Policy, Vol. 27, No. 0, (2013), 1-10.
- Armstrong V.N., "Vessel Optimisation for Low Carbon Shipping." Ocean Engineerin, Vol. 73, (2013), pp 195-207.
- Vergara J, McKesson C. and Walczak M., "Sustainable Energy for the Marine Sector." Energy Policy, Vol. 49, No. 0, (2012), pp 333-45.
- Tsolaki E. and Diamadopoulos E., "Technologies for Ballast Water Treatment: A Review", Journal of Chemical Technology and Biotechnology, Vol. 85, (2010), pp 19-32.
- Poulsen R.T. and Johnson H., "The Logic of Business vs. the Logic of Energy Management Practice: Understanding the Choices and Effects of Energy Consumption Monitoring Systems in Shipping Companies", Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 66, (2016), pp 317-27.
- Jafarzadeh S. and Utne I.B., "A Framework to Bridge the Energy Efficiency Gap in Shipping" Energy, Vol. 69, (2014), pp 603-12.
- Johnson H., Johansson M. and Andersson K., "Barriers to Improving Energy Efficiency in Short Sea Shipping: An Action Research Case Study", Journal of Cleaner Production, Vol. 66, (2014), pp 317-27.
- Sorrell S. et al., “Reducing Barriers to Energy Efficiency in Public and Private Organizations”, Sussex, UK: Science and Policy Technology Research (SPRU), University of Sussex, (2000).
- Lai K.H. et al., "Green Shipping Practices in the Shipping Industry: Conceptualization, Adoption, and Implications", Resources, Conservation and Recycling, Vol. 55, (2011), pp 631-638.
- Poulsen R.T. and Sornn-Friese H., "Achieving Energy Efficient Ship Operations Under Third Party Management: How do Ship Management Models Influence Energy Efficiency?", Research in Transportation Business & Management, Vol.17, (2015), pp 41-52.
- Rahim M.M., Islam T. and Kuruppu S., "Regulating Global Shipping Corporations' Accountability for Reducing Greenhouse Gas Emissions in the Seas." Marine Policy, Vol. 69, (2016), pp 159-70.
- Stevens L., et al., "Is New Legislation Stimulating the Implementation of Sustainable and Energy-Efficient Maritime Technologies?", Research in Transportation Business & Management, Vol. 17, (2015), pp 14-25.
- EU, “Regulation 2015/757 of the European Parliament and of the European Council on the Monitoring, Reporting and Verification of Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Maritime Transport, and amending Directive 2009/16/EC”, (2015).
- IMO MEPC, “Amendments to the Annex of Protocol of 1997 to Amend the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships, 1973, as Modified by the Protocol of 1978 Relating Thereto. Amendments to MARPOL Annex VI. MEPC 70/18/Add.1”, (2016).
- Lloyd's Register, European Union Regulation and Monitoring, Reporting and Verification of Carbon Dioxide from Ships, in Final Legislative Stages, Executive Summary, Lloyds Register, (2014).
- Hughes, E. “MARPOL Annex VI – an Update of International Regulatory Developments for Prevention of Air Pollution and the Energy Efficiency of Ships”, (2016).
- Stopford M., “Maritime Economics”, 3rd edition, Routledge, (2009).
- Ballassen V. et al., "Monitoring, Reporting and Verifying Emissions in the Climate Economy", Nature Climate Change, Vol. 5, (2015), pp 319-328.
- Schakenbach J., Vollaro R. and Forte R., "Fundamentals of Successful Monitoring, Reporting, and Verification Under a Cap-and-Trade Program" Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association, Vol. 56, (2006), pp 1576-1583.
- Walsh C. and Bows A., "Size matters! Exploring the Importance of Vessel Characteristics to Inform Estimates of Shipping Emissions" Applied Energy, Vol.98, (2012), pp 128-137.
- Kitada M. and Ölcer A., “Managing people and technology: The challenges in CSR and energy efficient shipping”, Research in Transportation Business & Management, Vol. 17, (2015), pp 36-40.
- Erbink J.J., et al., “Scheepvaartmodellering fase 2: in consensus naar een nationale aanbeveling” (in Dutch), Report no. 50964435-TOS/HSM 10-4539, KEMA, (2011).
- Jenkins C., Chadwick A. and Hovorka S.D., “The state of the art in monitoring and verification -Ten years on”, International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control, Vol. 40, (2015), pp 312-349.
- Johnson H. and Anderson K., “Barriers to energy efficiency in shipping”, WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs, (2014).
- Faber J., Nelissen D. and Smit M., “Monitoring of bunker fuel consumption”, Delft, CE Delft, (2013).
- California Environmental Protection Agency. “2007 Ocean-Going Ship Survey”, Appendix C. Stationary Source Division Emissions Assessment Branch, (2007).
- Hulskotte J.H.J. and Denier van der Gon H.A.C., “Fuel consumption and associated emissions from seagoing ships at berth derived from an on-board survey”, Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 44, (2010), pp 1229-1236.
- Dinh T., “Source inventory: Tugs and Towboats, Dredge vessels and Others” Air Resource Board, https://www.arb.ca.gov/homepage.htm, (1999).
- Kousoulidou M. et al., “Use of portable emissions measurement system (PEMS) for the development and validation of passenger car emission factors”, Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 64, (2013), pp 329-338.
- Maldonado H., “Evaluation of Portable Emission Measurement Systems (PEMS) for Inventory Purposes and the Not-To-Exceed Heavy-Duty Diesel Engine Regulation”, Report, Research Division California Air Resources Board, (2006).
- Jalkanen J.-P. et al., “Extension of an assessment model of ship traffic exhaust emissions for particulate matter and carbon monoxide”, Atmospheric Chemistry and Physics, Vol. 12, (2012), pp 2641-2659.
- Denier van der Gon H.A.C. and Hulskotte J., “Methodologies for estimating shipping emissions in the Netherlands- A documentation of currently used emission factors and data on related activity”, Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency – Report 500099012, Netherlands Research Program on Particulate Matter, (2010).
- IMO, “EEDI – rational, safe and effective”, http://www.imo.org/en/MediaCentre/HotTopics/GHG/Pages/EEDI.aspx, (2012).
- Acomi, N. and Acomi O.C., “Improving the Voyage Energy Efficiency by Using EEOI”, Procedia -Social and Behavioral Sciences, Vol. 138, (2014), pp 531-536.
- Entec UK Limited, “Service Contract on Ship missions: Assignment, Abatement and Market-based Instruments Task 2c – SO2”, European Commission Directorate General Environment Abatement -Final Report, (2005).
- EU, “Directive 2010/30/EU of the European Parliament and of the European Council on the indication by labelling and standard product information of the consumption of energy and other resources by energy-related products”, (2010).
- EU, “Regulation 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the European Council establishing a scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the Community and amending Council Directive 96/61/EC”, (2003).
- Grote M., Williams I. and Preston J., "Direct Carbon Dioxide Emissions from Civil Aircraft", Atmospheric Environment, Vol. 95, (2014), pp 214-224.