IAMU Research Project FY2016 Final Report
Aligning the Course Learning Outcomes of Maritime Business Degrees with Industry Preferred Skill Sets to Increase Student Employability in the Onshore Maritime Industry
| Publication Year | 2017 |
| Research Coordinator | Shu-Ling (Peggy) Chen |
| Research Partners | Stephen Cahoon; Hilary Pateman; Prashant Bhaskar; Grace Wang; James Parsons |
| Publisher | International Association of Maritime Universities (IAMU) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.68436/r20160405 |
Abstract
This project investigates whether the Course Learning Outcomes (CLOs) of maritime business degree meet the specific employability requirements of the onshore sector of the maritime industry. It firstly identifies common employability skills embedded in the CLOs of maritime business degrees by undertaking a comparison of existing CLOs between universities. Secondly, it interviewed and surveyed senior managers in the onshore maritime sectors in Australia, the US and Canada to investigate current and future industry employability skills required for maritime business graduates. Thirdly, these industry-focused employability skills sets were used for developing a mapping tool to evaluate alignment between the industry preferred employability skills sets and the universities’ CLOs and curriculum. Strategies for improvement of the CLOs and curriculum of maritime business degrees are recommended to align with employer-identified future skills to enhance students’ employability in the onshore maritime industry.
Executive summary
The maritime industry underpins international business and world trade. As to be expected, business management is critical for the maritime industry, requiring highly trained individuals and teams to lead the development, implementation and control of sound contemporary management practices. Maritime business degrees are developed by universities to meet such demand by providing graduates with sufficient skills for the onshore business-related roles. This project addresses the gap between the employability skills embedded in the Course Learning Outcomes (CLOs) and the specific employability requirements of the onshore sector of the maritime industry. More specifically, the project investigates current and future industry employability skills for maritime business graduates to succeed in the onshore industry. The project also develops strategies for aligning these skills with CLOs and the curriculum of maritime business degrees.
In examining how employability skills are currently embedded in universities’ curriculums, this project compared nine CLOs of maritime business undergraduate programmes from seven IAMU and two non-IAMU maritime universities. The CLOs in those maritime business degree programmes describe expectations that maritime business graduates should have broad and coherent general business and maritime business related knowledge and be able to apply this knowledge when undertaking professional work. The knowledge includes cognitive skills such as critical thinking; practical skills such as problem solving, research skills, application of knowledge; and transferable skills including communication, self-management, teamwork, and the use of computer and IT skills in a maritime business and management context. In addition, the CLOs suggest that graduates should be able to demonstrate a global perspective, and conduct themselves in a professional, socially responsible and ethical manner in life and in diverse business environments.
This project undertook a two-stage data collection involving firstly focus groups and individual interviews, and secondly, an online survey. In relation to the focus group and individual interviews, which were undertaken to explore industry perspectives on employability skills, these occurred with 27 senior industry managers in onshore maritime organisations in Australia, the US and Canada. The results of this first stage of the empirical study revealed that communication, adaptability and flexibility, an inquisitive mind, self-management, analytical and problem-solving, interpersonal skills, computer skills, and team work are essential employability skills required by the onshore maritime industry. The senior managers also suggested twenty topics of specific maritime business knowledge that are required to work in the various onshore maritime related organisations. They also identified that the future trend for the maritime industry is the adoption of automation and the utilisation of technology and information systems, therefore, computer skills and technology application are skills of growing importance for maritime business graduates. Regardless of changes in the future, adaptability continues to be an important skill because it is a continually evolving industry that will require graduates to be agile in their approach to the ever-changing environment.
The skills embedded in CLOs and the skills required by the onshore maritime industry commonly harmonise in areas such as knowledge, self-management and computer/IT skills. However, modifying CLOs related to communication and problem solving to give more specific emphasis, depth of study and focus may benefit industry as universities will be providing more comprehensive skill sets for these critical areas. In addition, including adaptability, flexibility and an inquiring mind in CLOs may increase the value of maritime business programmes to the dynamism and complexity that are inherent in the maritime industry.
In terms of the second stage of the empirical study, 117 senior managers in the onshore maritime industry in Australia, the US and Canada responded to the online survey. The senior managers confirmed that communication was the most important employability skill, followed by, problem solving, adaptability, self-management, team work, and digital literacy and technology. Seventeen (17) topics of specific maritime business knowledge skills were deemed by the senior managers to be of moderate to great importance. The online survey also found that technological change may drive the need to change some skills/knowledge in the future. Demand for digital literacy and technology knowledge and skills have for example already been increasing. However, a skills focus for maritime business graduates will not be creating the technology itself but in the use and management of technology, computer skills, and data management (eg big data) including monitoring, analysis, problem detection and solving.
In relation to the future skills/knowledge required from maritime business degree graduates in 10 years’ time, communication and adaptability are still recognised as the most important ones. This includes that maritime business graduates should be able to adopt new technology as a means for communication. Several respondents also expressed that graduates could be equipped with a higher level of computer skills, have strong work ethics and multilingual skills.
As a result of the examination of the universities’ CLOs and the two-stage empirical study, this project developed a mapping tool that determines alignment between the curriculum and CLOs of maritime business degrees and the industry required employability skills. The mapping tool identifies in-depth both learning activities and assessment items that will incorporate transferable skills and both specific maritime industry and specialist knowledge. Utilising the mapping tool results is a vital means to inform curriculum development.
Several recommendations are provided for maritime business degree providers to align their curriculum and industry employability skills. These include mapping curriculum regularly; developing transferable skills within the context of the maritime industry; implementing work integrated learning such as being involved with a mock organisation; hosting regular Industry Liaison/Advisory Committee meetings; inviting industry leaders for presentation; promoting student memberships of relevant industry associations; incorporating applied use of technology throughout the course; and considering incorporating non-specialist units into the curriculum. This research suggests several further studies. These include testing the mapping tool developed in this project by its use in IAMU member universities which offer maritime business degrees; and conducting surveys to maritime business graduates who are working in the maritime industry to receive their perceptions on employability skills. Additionally, this research can be extended further by involving more maritime universities in particular in both Asia and Europe to validate the results of this research.
Keywords
Employability Skills, Onshore Maritime Industry, Maritime Business Degrees, Course
References
- Hillage J. and Pollard E., “Employability: developing a framework for policy analysis”, Research Brief 85, Department for Education and Employment, Great Britain, (1989).
- Bennett D., Richardson S. and MacKinnon P., “Enacting strategies for graduate employability: How universities can best support students to develop generic skills Part A”.: Australian Government, Office for Learning Canberra, ACT and Teaching, Department of Education and Training, (2016).
- Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry & Business Council of Australia, “Employability skills for the future”, Department of Education, Science and Training, Commonwealth of Australia, (2002).
- Yorke M., “Employability in higher education: what it is – what it is no”, Learning and Employability Series One, Enhancing Student Employability Co-ordination Team (ESECT) and Higher Education Academy (HEA), (2006), <https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/system/files/id116_employability_in_higher_education_336.pdf > (accessed 17.04.27).
- Australian Qualifications Framework Council, “Australian qualifications framework”, 2nd edition, Australian Qualifications Framework Council, (2013).
- Bennett N., Dunne E. and Carre´ C., “Patterns of core and generic skill provision in higher education”, Higher Education, (1999), Vol. 37, pp. 71-93
- Yorke M. and Knight PT., “Learning and employability series 1: Embedding employability into the curriculum”, The Higher Education Academy, (2006).
- Pool LD. and Sewell P., “The key to employability: developing a practical model of graduate employability”, Education + Training, Vol 49, No.4, (2007), pp. 277-289.
- Sumanasiri EGT., Yajid MSA. and Khatibi, A., “Review of literature on graduate employability”, Journal of Studies in Education, Vol. 5, No.3, (2015), pp.75-88.
- Cole D. and Tibby M., “Defining and developing your approach to employability: A framework for higher education institutions”, The Higher Education Academy, (2013), <https://www.heacademy.ac.uk/system/files/resources/employability_framework.pdf>, (accessed 17.04.20).
- Storen LA. And Aamodt PO., “The quality of higher education and employability of graduates”, Quality in Higher Education, Vol. 16, No. 3, (2010), pp. 297-313.
- HEFCE, “Opportunity, choice and excellence in higher education”, Higher Education Funding Council, (2011), <http://www.hestem.ac.uk/sites/default/files/hefce_opportunity_choice_and_excellence_in_higher _education.pdf> (accessed 17.04.13).
- Precision Consultancy & BIHECC, “Graduate employability skills”, Precision Consultancy, Melbourne, (2007).
- DIICSRTE & DEEWR, “Core skills for work developmental framework: The framework”, Department of Industry, Innovation, Climate Change, Science, Research and Tertiary Education (DIICSRTE) & Department of Education, Employment and Workplace Relations (DEEWR), Commonwealth of Australia, (2013).
- CBI, “Working towards your future: making the most of your time in higher education”, CBI, London, (2011), <http://aces.shu.ac.uk/employability/resources/CBI_NUS_Employability%20report_May%202011.pdf> (accessed 17.04.13).
- Australian Technology Network, “Generic capabilities of ATN university graduates”, Australian Government Department of Education, Training and Youth Affairs, (2000), < http://www.clt.uts.edu.au/ATN.grad.cap.project.index.html> (accessed 16.09.19).
- Sumsion J. and Goodfellow J., “Identifying generic skills through curriculum mapping: a critical evaluation”, Higher Education Research & Development, Vol. 23, (2004), pp. 329-346.
- Dowling D., Rose S. and O'SHEA É.. “Reconsidering humanities programmes in Australian universities-embedding a new approach to strengthen the employability of humanities graduates by empowering them as global citizens”, Social Alternatives, Vol. 34, No. 2, (2015), pp. 52-62.
- University of Tasmania, ‘Graduate Statement’, “Degrees of difference: the University of Tasmania education model”, university of Tasmaina, Hobart, (2016).
- Deakin University, “Deakin graduate learning outcomes”, Deakin University, (2016), <http://www.deakin.edu.au/about-deakin/teaching-and-learning/deakin-graduate-learning-outcomes>(accessed 16.10.03)
- Australian Business Deans Council, “Learning standards”, Australian Business Deans Council, (2016), <http://www.abdc.edu.au/pages/learning-standards.html> (accessed 16.10.03).
- Hancock P., Freeman M. and ASOCIATES, “Business, Management and economics: learning and teaching academic standards statement for accounting”, Australian Learning & Teaching Council, (2010).
- MLM, “Course learning outcomes of Bachelor of Business”, Department of Maritime and Logistics Management, Australian Maritime College, (2017).
- Biggs J. and TANG C., “Teaching for quality learning at university”, Open University Press/McGraw-Hill, (2011).
- University of Tasmania, “Intended learning outcomes”, University of Tasmania, (2016). <http://www.teaching-learning.utas.edu.au/ilo> (accessed 2016.10.05).
- Bennett D., Richardson S. and MacKinnon P., “Enacting strategies for graduate employability: How universities can best support students to develop generic skills Part B”.: Australian Government, Office for Learning Canberra, ACT and Teaching, Department of Education and Training, (2016).
- HEA, “Framework for embedding employability in higher education”, The Higher Education Academy, (2015), <http://www.employability.ed.ac.uk/documents/HEA-Embedding_employability_in_HE.pdf>, (accessed 17.04.27).
- Ng AKY., Koo AC. and Ho WC. “The motivations and added values of embarking on postgraduate professional education: Evidences from the maritime industry”, Transport Policy, Vol.16, Issue 5, (2009), pp. 251-258.
- Ng AKY., Koo AC. and Pallis AA., “Professionalization of the shipping industry via postgraduate education”, Ocean & Coastal Management, Vol. 54, Issue 5, (2011), pp. 364-373.
- Pallis AA. and Ng AKY., “Pursuing maritime education: an empirical study of students’ profiles, motivations and expectations”, Maritime Policy and Management, Vol. 38, Issue 4, (2011), pp.369-393.
- Lau Yl. and Ng AKY., “The motivations and expectations of students pursuing maritime education”, WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs, (2015), Vol 14, pp. 313-331.
- Ng, JM. and Yip TL., “Maritime education in a transdisciplinary world: The case of Hong Kong”, The Asian Journal of Shipping and Logistics, Vol. 25, No. 1, (2009), pp.69-82.
- Murphy PR. and Poist RF.. “A comparison of headhunter and practitioner views regarding skill requirements of senior-level logistics professionals”, Logistics and Transportation Review, Vo. 27, (1991), pp. 277-294.
- Murphy PR. and Poist RF., “Skill requirements of senior-level logisticians: practitioner perspectives”, International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, Vol. 21, (1991), pp. 3-14.
- Murphy PR. and Poist RF., “Skill requirements of senior-level logistics executive: An empirical assessment”, Journal of Business Logistics, Vol. 12, (1991), pp.73-94.
- Razzaque MA. and Sirat MSB., “Skill requirements: perception of the senior Asian logisticians”, International Journal of Physical Distribution & Logistics Management, Vol. 31, (2001), pp. 374-395.
- Murphy PR. and Poist RF., “Skill requirements of contemporary senior-and entry-level logistics managers: a comparative analysis”. Transportation Journal, Vol. 45, Issue 3, (2006), pp. 46-60.
- Thai VV., Cahoon S. and Tram HT., ”Skill requirements for logistics professionals: findings and implications”, Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, Vol. 23, (2011), pp. 553-574.
- Jossec G. and Shanahan O., “Training the logisticians of the future: skill implications of technological changes in the transport and logistics industry”, Australasian Transport Research Forum (ATRF), Sydney, (2015).
- Fernando S., Sigera I. and Cahoon S., “Knowledge, skills and attitudes: perceptions of senior managers in the Sri Lankan shipping industry”, International Association of Maritime Economists Conference (IAME13), Marseille, (2013), pp. 1-17.
- Han T-C. and Li TH., “Applying the Rasch model to construct the shipping industry employability indicators”, Journal of Marine Science and Technology, Vol.23, No.5, (2015), pp.741-747.
- Transport and Logistics Industry Skills Council, “Transport and logistics environmental scan”, Department of Education and Training, Australia Government, and Transport and Logistics Industry Skills Council, (2015).
- Transport and Logistics Industry Skills Council, “Overview of Maritime sector”, Transport and Logistics Industry Skills Council, (2016), <http://tlisc.org.au/maritime/> (accessed 16.10.05).
- Transport and Logistics Industry Skills Council, “Overview of ports sector”, Transport and Logistics Industry Skills Council, (2016). <http://tlisc.org.au/ports/> (accessed 16.10.05).
- The Critical Thinking Community, “Defining critical thinking”, (2017), <http://www.criticalthinking.org/pages/index-of-articles/defining-critical-thinking/766>(accessed 17.01.20).
- Armstrong JS. and Overton TS., “Estimating nonresponse bias in mail surveys” Journal of Marketing Research, (1977), Vol. 14, pp. 396-402.
- Lindner JR. Murphy TH. and Briers GE., “Handling nonresponse in social science research”, Journal of Agricultural Education, (2001), Vol. 42, No. 4, pp. 43-53.
- Borg WR. and Gall MD., “Educational research: an introduction”. Longman, New York and London, (1983).