IAMU Research Project for Young Academic Staff FY2019 Final Report
Evaluating cybersecurity in the maritime industry
| Publication Year | 2020 |
| Research Coordinator | Chia-Hsun Chang |
| Research Partners | Wei Zhang; Wenming Shi; Changki Park |
| Publisher | International Association of Maritime Universities (IAMU) |
| DOI | https://doi.org/10.68436/ryas201902 |
Abstract
Cybersecurity has become an important issue in the maritime industry due to many reported cyberattack incidents that caused a lot of economic loss, personal or company information breach, and so on. However, there is limited research for maritime cybersecurity in the existing literature. This research aims to conduct a risk assessment for cybersecurity in the maritime sector. In order to achieve that research aim, the definition of cybersecurity and current maritime cybersecurity issues are firstly reviewed. Following that, 34 cyber threats under eight cyber threat categories in the maritime industry are identified through systematic literature review. To deal with the identified threats, seven risk control options are also identified. A questionnaire is designed based on the literature review and distributed to validate the identified cybersecurity threats and explore more that are not identified during the literature review. Based on the results of the questionnaire, several top threats under each threat category are selected to conduct another questionnaire to collect the likelihood, consequence, and probability of failure detection with degree-of-belief-based five-point Likert scale. Through a rule-based Bayesian Network analysis, we found that the category of “Phishing” and the threat of “Connecting your infected USB or removable media to connect computers/navigation systems” contribute the most to the maritime cybersecurity risk.
Executive summary
Cybersecurity has recently received considerable attention in the maritime industry due to many reported cyberattack incidents that caused a lot of economic loss, personal or company information breach. In order to mitigate the effects of maritime cyber-attacks, this research aims to conduct a comprehensive risk assessment for cybersecurity in the maritime sector and proposes the following three research objectives: 1) To identify threats related to maritime cybersecurity; 2) To evaluate cybersecurity risk; 3) Provide some risk control options for maritime cyber threats.
To achieve the above three objectives, we conduct a systematic literature review and a first-run questionnaire with 31 experts in the maritime industry and academia, followed by a detailed investigation of the causes and consequences of the threats and a comprehensive discussion of potential solutions. Based on the results of the first-run questionnaire, eight maritime cyber threat categories are identified, including Phishing, Malware, Men-in-the-middle, Ransomware, Theft of credential, DDoS, Human error, and Using outdated IT. Each category includes several threats in detail. After that, a second-run questionnaire is further designed and conducted in this research to identify the cyber threats in the maritime industry and to collect their likelihood, consequence, and probability of failure detection with degree-of-belief-based five-point Likert scale. In addition, a variety of data analytical techniques, including Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) with Rule-based Bayesian Network (RBN), and a three-dimensional (3D) risk matrix are used to quantify the cybersecurity risk in the maritime sector.
The main findings of this research are as follows. On one hand, a list of cyber threats and cyber threat categories are identified through a systematic literature review and validated by experts. As indicated, the category of “Phishing” contributes the most to the maritime cybersecurity risk, with the category’s value more than 40. By checking the aggregated raw data, the consequence of the three parameters (i.e. likelihood, consequence, and probability of the threat been undetected) have the highest values. This indicates that the maritime industry should try to find some methods either to mitigate the impacts of the consequences once phishing happens or to prevent them happen from reducing the likelihood or probability of the threat been undetected. However, the top values are just in the middle between UR3 (27) and UR4 (64), which indicates that most of the respondents feel that cyber threats do not significantly impact on the maritime industry. On the other side, the lowest cyber threat category is “Using outdated IT” with a value lower than UR3 (27), which refers to that the respondents do not think this is an important factor that contributes to the maritime cybersecurity risk. By checking the aggregated data, we found that the likelihood of the three cyber threats are the lowest among the three parameters, which imply that most of the respondents believe that their companies have updated the IT to the latest version to protest the damage from the cyber-attacks.
On the other hand, from the cyber threat aspect, the most crucial one is µAccessing links from impersonation emails (e.g. bank, credit card company, insurance company, etc.)’, following by µDownloading attached files from impersonation emails (e.g. bank, credit card company, insurance company, etc.)’, and µLacking knowledge of cybersecurity (i.e. facing a new situation and do not know how to deal with it) with threat values more than 40. Sea crews and company staffs might attempt to operate navigational or company’s IT systems in convenient ways, which might cause more cyber vulnerability and a higher likelihood to be cyberattacked. However, these three cyber threats can all be avoided through high cybersecurity awareness, which is established by regular training and education.
Despite these significant findings, several limitations still exist in this research. First, we have limited replies from the target sample for both the first-run and second-run questionnaires. This might be due to the complicated questionnaires that are not easy to answer. We will collect more replies (e.g. expand the regions to other continents such as Asia and America) in the future to achieve acceptable replies numbers for further statistics analysis. Secondly, the respondents’ background may be another factor that impacts on the reliability of the result. However, all respondents have some experience related to cybersecurity issues, although maritime cybersecurity is an emerging issue and everyone has different experience with such issue. Yet, the future research can conduct analysis with different weighting for people with different levels of familiarity to the maritime cybersecurity. Thirdly, although there were some operation technology (OT) items listed in the first-run questionnaire, their mean values are not higher than the threshold and thus are not listed in the second-run questionnaire. The second-run questionnaire is used to evaluate the cyber threats with three parameters (likelihood, consequence and probability of failure undetected), it will be more appropriate to list relative important threats based on the results of the first-run questionnaire to increase respondents’ willingness answering the questionnaire. Apart from that, most of OT systems will transfer the signal to IT systems and thus the results can be deemed as a further risk assessment. However, the significant impact of OT system are also vulnerabilities to maritime cybersecurity and need to be considered as well. For the further research, it is suggested to address more on OT perspective to fill the gap. Fourthly, the consequence can be different types. In our research, the consequences are aggregated. For further research, there is a need to investigate the details of different consequence types to analyse the consequence from different aspects. All these point out the potential direction for the future research.
Keywords
Cybersecurity; maritime industry; risk management; Ruled-based Bayesian Network
References
- UNCTAD, Review of Maritime Transport, 2016, Available at: http://unctad.org/en/PublicationsLibrary/rmt2016_en.pdf
- Svilicic, B., Kamahara, J., Rooks, M., & Yano, Y. (2019). Maritime Cyber Risk Management: An Experimental Ship Assessment. The Journal of Navigation, 72(5), 1108-1120.
- Novet, J., Shipping company Maersk says June cyberattack could cost it up to $300 million, 2017, Available at: https://www.cnbc.com/2017/08/16/maersk-says-notpetya-cyberattack-could-cost-300-million.html
- World Maritime News, COSCO Shipping Lines Falls Victim to Cyber Attack, 2018, Available at: https://worldmaritimenews.com/archives/257665/cosco-shipping-lines-falls-victim-to-cyber-attack/
- Julisch, K., Understanding and overcoming cyber security anti-patterns, Computer Networks, 2013, 57 (1), 2206-2211.
- IMO, guidelines on maritime cyber risk management, 2017 MSC-FAL.1/Circ.3REFERENCES.
- Caponi, S., and Belmont, K. Maritime cybersecurity: A growing threat goes unanswered, Intellectual Property and Technology Law Journal, 2015, 27 (1), 16-18.
- Craigen, D., Diakun-Thibault, N., & Purse, R. Defining cybersecurity, Technology Innovation Management Review, 2014, 4(10), pp.13-21
- Schaik, P., Jeske, D., Onibokun, J., Coventry, L., Jansen, J., and Kusev, P. Risk perceptions of cyber-security and precautionary behavior, Computers in Human Behavior, 2017, 75 (1), 547-559.
- Bendovschi, A., Cyber-attacks±trends, patterns and security countermeasures, Procedia Economics and Finance, 2015, 28, pp. 24-31.
- Department of Justice in the U.S cyberattack, 2016, Available at: https://edition.cnn.com/2016/02/08/politics/hackers-fbi-employee-info/index.html
- Equifax, 2017, Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-41575188
- Marriott hotels cyberattack, 2018, Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-46401890
- IRISL, 2015, Available at: https://www.joc.com/maritime-news/container-lines/carriers-threatened-cyber-attacks-experts-warn_20150303.html
- Antwerp Bateman, T., Police warning after drug traffickers' cyber-attack, BBC News, 2013. Available at: http://www.bbc.corn/news/world-europe-24539417
- PORTSTRATEGY, 2017, Available at: https://www.portstrategy.com/news101/port-operations/planning-and-design/cyber-security-feature
- Linton Art, Port Authority Role in Cyber-Security, Linked in, 2016, Available at: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/port-authority-role-cybersecurity-art-linton
- MODU, 2013, Available at: https://www.csis.org/blogs/strategic-technologies-blog/coast-guard-commandant-addresses-cybersecurity-vulnerabilities
- Saul, J., Cyber Threats prompt return of radio for ship navigation, Reuters, 2017, Available at: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-shipping-gpscyber-idUSKBN1AN0H
- COSCO World Maritime News, COSOCO shipping lines falls victim of cyberattack, 2018, Available at: https://worldmaritimenews.com/archives/257665/cosco-shipping-lines-falls-victim-to-cyber-attack/
- Information Security Newspaper, Hacking attack in port of Barcelona, 2018,Available at: https://www.securitynewspaper.com/2018/09/26/hacking-attack-in-port-of-barcelona/
- BBC New, San Diego port hit by ransomware attack, 2018, Available at: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-45677511
- Schr|der-Hinrichs, J. U., µHuman and Organizational Factors in the Maritime World ± are We Keeping up to Speed?’, WMU Journal of Maritime Affairs, 2010, 9 (1), pp.1±3.
- Heij, C. and Knapp, S., µPredictive Power of Inspection Outcomes for Future Shipping Accidents ± An Empirical Appraisal with Special Attention for Human Factor Aspects’, Maritime Policy and Management, 2018, 45 (5), pp.604-621.
- Cole, Connected Ships and Cybersecurity Frank J Coles, Transas CEO Shipping Insight Fleet Optimization Conference, 2017.
- North P&I club, Cyber risk in sipping, North of England P&I group, 2017
- Sen, R., Chpter 9. Cyber and information threats to seaports and ships. McNicholas, MA, Maritime Security, 2016, 2, pp. 281- 302
- Jones, K. D., Tam, K., & Papadaki, M.,Threats and impacts in maritime cyber security, 2016.
- BIMCO, The Guidelines on Cyber Security Onboard Ships (Version 3), 2018.
- Ahokas Jenna, The finnish maritime sector and cybersecurity, PUBLICATIONS OF THE HAZARD PROJECT, 2019, University of Turku.
- IET, Code of Practice, Cyber security for Ports and Port System, Available at: https://cybersail.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/IETCyber-Security-Code-of-Practice-for-Ports-Port-Systems.pdf
- Japan P&I Club, Cyber risk and Cyber security countermeasures, 2018, Available at: https://www.piclub.or.jp/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/Loss-Prevention-Bulletin-Vol.42-Full.pdf
- Teoh, C.S. and Mahmood, A.K., Cybersecurity Workforce Development for Digital Economy. The Educational Review, 2018, USA, 2(1), pp.136-146.
- Fayi, S.Y.A., What Petya/NotPetya ransomware is and what its remidiations are, In Information Technology-New Generations, pp. 93-100, Springer, Cham.
- COSCO JCO.com, Cosco’s pre-cyberattack efforts protected network, 2018, Available at: https://www.joc.com/maritime-news/container-lines/cosco/cosco%E2%80%99s-pre-cyber-attack-efforts-protected-network_20180730.html
- Fitton, O., Prince, D., Germond, B., & Lacy, M. (2015). The future of maritime cyber security, 2015, Lancaster University.
- Zohar, D., Safety climate in industrial organizations: theoretical and applied implications. Journal of Applied Psychology, 1980, 65, pp. 96-102.
- Schwatka, N. V., Hecker, S., & Goldenhar, L. M., Defining and measuring safety climate: a review of the construction industry literature. Annals of occupational hygiene, 2016, 60(5), pp. 537-550.